I took Ella to my vet this morning for a well puppy visit. Dr Dally, has been my vet for my previous two Shelties and is familiar with me and my lifestyle. This is what he told me when I voiced my concern over her extreme fear. "Although I am not a behaviorist, in my opinion she is a full step beyond fear. I can tell she likes people as she will sit near my legs and is not in the farthest corner of the room for the most part. But, we have been in here for 25 mins, in a relatively quiet room, just the two of us, and she is trembling and shaking as much as when she first came in the room. She will not take a treat and I have the best treats. She will claw at the door to get away from me at times. She definitely will need alot of socialization, but even with than I am not sure this dog will be able to will walk without fear in public places. If you force me to give you a opinion, that I am hesitate to do, I would suggest you return her to the breeder." My head is spinning. I am so confused and disappointed. I could use some of your opinions to know what I should do.