I'm glad other people feed their shelties 1/4 cup per feeding. I started noticing that mine looked sorta like a sausage on toothpicks, that's when I reduced his feeding dramatically and cut out all treats! I'm not sure if it's made a difference or not, but I notice when I bath him, he shrinks! 
My boyfriend acts like I'm committing a sin! How dare I cut an overweight dog's food back. No gratuitus treat feeding? And I call myself an animal lover. Green beans and carrots aren't "treats", dog treats are treats. It's true what they say, training never truly ends...
. My boys think that the fact it comes from my hand directly, it is a treat.
Heck, I've even fooled my border collie into taking medicine directly (without wrapping in food). Here's how I imagine his thought process: #1- She's got something in her hand and calling me, must be a treat! #2. She's making me "do" something for it (simple trick). I get treats for doing a trick, so it really must be a yummy treat.

My boyfriend acts like I'm committing a sin! How dare I cut an overweight dog's food back. No gratuitus treat feeding? And I call myself an animal lover. Green beans and carrots aren't "treats", dog treats are treats. It's true what they say, training never truly ends...

. My boys think that the fact it comes from my hand directly, it is a treat. Heck, I've even fooled my border collie into taking medicine directly (without wrapping in food). Here's how I imagine his thought process: #1- She's got something in her hand and calling me, must be a treat! #2. She's making me "do" something for it (simple trick). I get treats for doing a trick, so it really must be a yummy treat.

That is too funny! I'm going to have to remember your trick.