Allergies help

I think the best answer to that question is there is no 'good' dry dog food

I'm not sure that this is a fair statement. It may be your opinion, but not everyone has the ability to feed their dogs raw (for any number of reasons) and suggesting that anyone feeding their dog dry food is not feeding their dog "good" food seems a little unfair. There are absolutely some bad dry dog foods out there, and dogfoodadvisor.com is a great resource. But I also believe that there are some great dry dog foods out there. So if raw seems overwhelming or impossible to the OP or anyone else reading, please don't feel like you're doing your dogs a disservice by feeding them dry food. We all do the best that we can for our pups! :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ann
Absolutely it was my opinion Corbinam, and I also believe that feeding a dog raw will always be better for the dog but I also understand that not everyone has the time or the financial ability to feed raw so then yes, they should feed a 'good quality' kibble. Sheltie forums is a place where people ask questions of others and that's what they get in return is opinions, the fact that your differs from mine doesn't offend me.
 
Not to start a fight, and I know we have been over this so many times before..... but why is it acceptable for the raw feeders to keep saying dry food is trash, while if anyone challenges raw feeding they get assaulted for not being 'open minded'? If I were to go on the raw board and say 'in my opinion there is no such thing as a 'good' raw diet' I do not believe that would be acceptable.
Just as with 'grain free', and so many other controversial feeding agendas, it is not 'just saying' to suggest that someone is hurting their pet by not feeding a certain way which you prefer, it has the potential to be harmful.
 
Personally, I would be afraid to mistake feeding raw as about proteins / vitamins.

Yes, everyone will hopefully do the best for our animals.
 
Chai has started chewing his feet. Food allergies are to blame. The vet has him taking Benadryl, and suggested changing his food. I feed him Beneful dry food, and Alpo canned food. I plan to switch him to cooked chicken that I prepare myself...but he still needs a dry food to be out between meals. What is the best healthy dry dog food to give to him?
Trying not to interfere with another veterinarian's work, but this statement confuses me. How do you know it is a food allergy? The main differential would be atopy, an environmental/inhalant allergy that is generally seasonal. And FAR more common. It is difficult to distinguish between the two - generally one thinks of a food allergy when it is always there, simmering along, and does not 'flare up' at certain times. However, while there is allergy testing (of more or less value) for atopy, there is no good test for food allergies. Food allergies are only really diagnosed by feeding a hypoallergenic diet for at least 6 weeks and seeing if it helps.
Trying a hypoallergenic diet is not difficult- they are available commercially in pet stores by such mainstay companies as Wellness and Natural Balance. They say "Limited Ingredient Diet' in big letters on the bag. These foods typically include only one protein and one carbohydrate, with a 'novel' protein like Duck, Venison, or Kangaroo, and a hypoallergenic carb like potatoes or sweet potatoes. Just read the labels.
Thus the statement 'My dog has been diagnosed with food allergies but I don't know what to feed him' is odd. Feeding the food that demonstrated it was a food allergy would be a good place to start, at least for awhile.
Again, I am not in the least suggesting in any way that your veterinarian was wrong, but more that asking a few questions like 'how do we know this is a food allergy and should we try a trial' would be in order.
 
Dr. Mac you just gave me, a feel good day. That is exactly what I feed my sheltie. She has Wellness and Natural Balance on her plate.
I love these two companies. Wellness turkey and Natural Balance salmon and sweet potato. Oh of course we serve in two separate bowls
for the Royal Highness.
I think its great you chimed in, more thoughts on what to do is a good thing. I just used my friend's idea from her vet to use Kroger
Athlete Foot Cream on a spot of fungus, the meds did not work on that spot, the cream did.
Thanks!!!
 
Back
Top