I respect your opinion.
I do think, though, that if a dog lives in a fenced area, he might wanna see what's on the other side. If he sees everything, but is told not to go, he doesn't feel «imprisoned», and therefore, doesn't feel the need to go there.
I might be wrong tho.
Also keep in mind that we never leave the house with the dog outside, and we always look out the window every few minutes to make sure he's within eyesight.
It's just reassuring to know that I can go outside to answer the phone or do something and not have to worry about the dog running away.
We also live in a very peaceful city, in a very peaceful suburban neighbourhood, so having the dog stolen is not a concern. There just is no crime here.
Needless to say, I don't leave him untied at someone else's place.
Forgive me for this,but I think you could be very passive on the point being,that people do take dogs,and dogs do for some reason or another get spooked even when they are used to surroundings.
That being said,I would never ever even knowing all 3 of our dogs have great recall,would I ever think its ok to leave one unattended with out a restriction of a fence. I do have fencing here,but if I were to be without one,I would not ever leave mine unattended for any period.If one has a dog,it is up to the owner to have the dog safe at all times,so that means a leash.
It only takes split seconds for someone to scoop up a dog. And honestly to me,it does not mean a hill of beans knowing that I personally know all my neighbors.People that don't live in neighborhoods so travel thru. I live in a very quiet residencial rural neighborhood,but I don't trust anyone.
I know for a fact,we are one of 3 families that own shelties in this town,they are valuable pets,and there is to much for puppy mills,people that sell dogs at flea markets.
We are approached more times than I care to,with people at flea markets when the boys are with us...with comments on "wow those are EXPENSIVE" dogs. I see the dollar signs in thier eyes.And these mostly are shady looking folks.
But that is only one aspect.Dogs are dogs,they chase,they get startled,and they run. I have read more than one plea from families looking for thier sheltie,and still some to this day are still not home.
Now on the flip side...my son has 2 tea cup chihuahua's. One never ever leaves Eric or Lynn's side.The other...is gone if she is allowed outside without a leash.It makes no differance if the pup has been with you from day one,no two dogs are alike. Lexie will leterally watch her sister Lucy run like a maniac up the road.So I do not feel it is safe.