I second the 'be a tree' method. Even though Pierre was too stubborn to comply, he knew what I wanted. His stubbornness and my being fed up with not actually walking anywhere led me to get the GentleLeader. I recommend a really good fit. Pierre has a short snout (not a Sheltie issue), so the strap was a little thick for his size. I wish they would use a rounded chord or something else for the petite sizes. Anyway, he hates it. We treated when we started it, let him wear it around, but he actually runs away when he sees the leash! After like 7 months of this, I'm done and will be going back to traditional collars. But every time he pulls and chokes himself and gets all grunty and coughy, I feel bad and wonder if I should be used the Leader again. Maybe a martingale would work?