Whoa, I never would had guess that this would get so many posts! I am glad I started it myself

*pats shelf on back*
Everyone is so helpful here!
Still having trouble really decided for myself what is best for my dogs. Ruckus has always been on natural food (taste of the wild, and diamond naturals), but has skin allergies, excessive shedding, and chronic colitis. That is actually what got me wondering enough to start this topic/debate. The vet of course is recommending a Science Diet food, or Iams healthy naturals.
I think Lynn could eat crap and dog just fine (not that I would feed alpo or anything like that)