It's taken awhile, but from our scales - not the vets and we weighed him the same day as the vet did when I had his Thyroid retested, Shiloh is down about 5 lbs. We have prevented him from stealing the cat foods.

The little thief still does steal some of our border collies food, if I don't watch him carefully. (Wish our border collie would just eat when fed instead of taking the whole night to eat.

) The weather has also gotten nicer, so Shiloh is able to go on longer walks. He enjoys being able to run off leash with Bandit, He still has more weight to take off. Thanks again for all the tips.