Caro
Moderator
None of those things worked for me either. Because of a body corporate problem I can't afford for the dogs to bark when the evil neighbour is home. Nowadays I just slip a bark collar over Deska's head and he knows he is not to bark (and Tully gives up on barking when Mr D doesnt). When he gets a bit too barky he wears it a couple of times and he settles back down.
I would really recommend trying one for your own sanity of nothing else. The beauty of a bark collar is the noise is coming from them - not you. I find it best works when used intermittently, I think shelties are smart enough not to need it on all the time.
This is the ultrasonic one I use (recently replaced under warranty as my old one was going thru batteries every 2 weeks)
http://www.amazon.com/Petsafe-PUSB-300-UltraLight-Collar-Attachment/dp/B00023CZLM
If you think she will persist through the sound of the ultrasonic, I have recommended this vibration collar to a few people who love it too. Just be aware that a sensitive dog might find it a bit overwhelming (deska wont move if he has this on)
http://www.dogtrainingstore.com/cgi-bin/FULLPRES.exe?PARTNUM=PT001
Here's Mr D with his petsafe collar
I would really recommend trying one for your own sanity of nothing else. The beauty of a bark collar is the noise is coming from them - not you. I find it best works when used intermittently, I think shelties are smart enough not to need it on all the time.
This is the ultrasonic one I use (recently replaced under warranty as my old one was going thru batteries every 2 weeks)
http://www.amazon.com/Petsafe-PUSB-300-UltraLight-Collar-Attachment/dp/B00023CZLM
If you think she will persist through the sound of the ultrasonic, I have recommended this vibration collar to a few people who love it too. Just be aware that a sensitive dog might find it a bit overwhelming (deska wont move if he has this on)
http://www.dogtrainingstore.com/cgi-bin/FULLPRES.exe?PARTNUM=PT001
Here's Mr D with his petsafe collar