I'm having problems teaching Yogi to hold the dumbell. If I throw it he's fine to run out and get it but I need to train him to sit and give it to me. Revel was trained the forced retrieve (held the dumbell in his closed mouth) and he has a solid retrieve. I'm training Yogi using the clicker (the forced retrieve wouldn't work with him). However, after 2 months we have got as far as him picking it up about 2" off the floor and if I put my hand underneath quickly enough I can catch it as he drops it but I can't seem to get him to make the connection to place it in my hand. Any thoughts of him sitting and holding it are a distant dream at the moment.
Yogi's trouble is he is fine holding something while he is moving, but he dosn't understand the concept of holding something in his mouth while he is stationary.
I suspect part of the problem is he will be 8 in august and for all those years he has been allowed to get away with throwing the dumbell/toy at me, so it is a case of old habits, but even when playing I've never seen him stand still and hold something.
He is in other respects a VERY keen worker, naturally attentive and unlike most shelties, is happy to do something over and over again.
Any suggestions please?
Yogi's trouble is he is fine holding something while he is moving, but he dosn't understand the concept of holding something in his mouth while he is stationary.
I suspect part of the problem is he will be 8 in august and for all those years he has been allowed to get away with throwing the dumbell/toy at me, so it is a case of old habits, but even when playing I've never seen him stand still and hold something.
He is in other respects a VERY keen worker, naturally attentive and unlike most shelties, is happy to do something over and over again.
Any suggestions please?

