Toys AND Treats

You know Koji is a total food hound. He's obviously like Ember. Will work for food ONLY. Not really, but you get the point. Koji didn't learn anything when I moved to tugging only. I mean, I tried everything. Even my trainers tried it and the quickest way for him to learn, enjoy it, and have it stick, was to have food. Koji isn't a big tugger AT all. And when I did have a bait pouch, the only reason he was interested in it is if 1. it was moving or 2. it had food inside. Don't get me wrong, he will pull on a toy, but it's not a "reward" it's just something fun to do until I toss it or open it up for a treat..........

With that, it got me thinking....if I was doing flyball, how would I reward Koji if I couldn't use food. I would throw the ball. If he brought it back to me, I'd bounce it to get him riled up, or pass it in front of his face saying something like "you want it? huh" you want it" and then throw it so he chases it. However, he is very movement oriented, so throwing it is more of a treat than retrieving or tugging.

Does Lexi have more fun chasing a ball down versus tugging? If so, why not toss the ball? Um, yeah, I'd ask flyball people first to see if that's a bad training technique. But, for myself, I think Koji would run to get a ball, and bring it back, if I would just throw the darn thing afterwards and make him chase it. THEN he'd love it big time. He'd prefer to get the ball, return it and get food more so though.

Lastly, I think Shelli mentioned this, maybe someone else. If Koji knows I have treats, but he needs to focus or do something else, I also wait him out. i.e. If I tell him to get his dragon toy, and he knows I have food, he'll wait me out. But, after awhile, I'll just shove him in the direction of the toy and eventually he'll get it. He learns that he can't have food unless he does what *I* want him to do first. Trust me, sometimes it's totally useless. But since he's so food motivated, I had to make sure he'd work for me if food was around (like at agility training - everyone has food). And he will work for me, BUT then when he's done, he'll go find food. i.e. he'll do a sequence, get a reward from me, then go to my trainer, who he KNOWS has better stuff and bark at her. BUT, the point is, he knows he has to work for me first.

I think Lexi just needs to learn her job first. And that's to focus. Keep remembering, she's a baby dog. How old is she? 2? I know Koji really couldn't focus well at all at that age. And from what Ortega says, he wont hit his prime focus stage for another year. lol.

BTW, good luck on whatever you try. You may to find something else that she loves. Maybe tugging just isn't it. Maybe it's chasing, like Koji.
 
Okay, I tried a few things...epic fail. And now I'm frustrated and I shouldn't be.

1) I decided to charge the ball by using the clicker. I've always known that my dogs are really bad at interacting with "props"...but this was pretty bad. She threw every trick at me that she knew, except for any interaction with the ball. I eventually got to a nose touch, but it was weak and she kept getting frustrated. I just don't think she'll ever hold it when I have a treat/clicker on me.

2) I decided to try rewarding Lexi for bringing the ball back with a treat. As soon as I knew she had the treat, she wouldn't get the ball. She would run to it, and run back. Then she started offering other behaviors (rolling over, etc...)

3) I tried to just get her to tug with treats around. She tugged for a little, then realized there were treats, and just stopped. So I decided to make tugging look like the most fun thing ever. I ran around, dragged the toy on the ground, cheered, etc...all these things would usually have Lexi super riled up and ready to play, but she just stared at me to get the treat.

10 minutes later, she brought the ball to me on her own and wanted to play fetch. ARGHHHHHH! I would love some help with even babier baby steps.

I agree with Caro, break it into smaller pieces and teach them separately. I am big double L person myself/ Lumper and Lurer/ so familiar with such frustration:sadsmile:
 
The rules state that you cannot throw the ball in the ring. You can bounce a ball, but no throwing. And throwing can be loosely defined - the judge here are very strict.

IMHO, I would not use treats at all. I believe you will get better results with no food. Why must you have both? If you are rewarding with a game of tug and you've trained her to LOVE the tug, that would be perfect. In flyball, the ball does not have to be the most important thing. Not all dogs charge down the lane because they love the ball. Most want the reward. Sure, Duncan loves the ball - he is insane about them - but he will trade it for a treat any day. You need something MORE valuable than the ball to get the dog back to you. Most people in flyball (in my area) use tugs without food.
 
Back
Top