Debarked Dogs

Status
Not open for further replies.
As somebody who would someday like to have another Sheltie, all of this talk about excessive barking is discouraging.

It seems fair to say that those of us posting on this thread are the people who have barkers, and multiple dogs, which increases the barking quotient. We're a small percentage overall of our Forum population. Not every Sheltie is a barker. Two of my three are not, and two of my previous Shelties weren't either.

I'm sure if you examine most any breed you'll find some who bark excessively and some who don't bark much at all. We once had a Pomeranian who could outshine any Sheltie I've ever had in the Barking Department.
 
It seems fair to say that those of us posting on this thread are the people who have barkers, and multiple dogs, which increases the barking quotient. We're a small percentage overall of our Forum population. Not every Sheltie is a barker. Two of my three are not, and two of my previous Shelties weren't either.

I'm sure if you examine most any breed you'll find some who bark excessively and some who don't bark much at all. We once had a Pomeranian who could outshine any Sheltie I've ever had in the Barking Department.

Absolutely Ann!

My family has four shelties one owned by my parents and three owned by my husband and I. Of these four only Ginny is a problem and its not even that she's having behavioral issues, she just expresses herself through barking. Everything she does is with a bark, she's one yappy little girl.

We're constantly trying to keep her calm to keep her yapping to a minimum and I'm beginning to think it may be better for her if we consider debarking her. How would you feel if someone was constantly telling you to hush and calm down every time you said a word?

She's such a good little girl, I couldn't ask for better. I would love for her to be able to express herself and play without us going out of our minds and telling her to hush and calm down.

One of these days I have to get a video of her barking in the house and when she plays outside...:eek2:
 
My mom said she doesn't remember our first sheltie barking too much and her second one didn't either. I can say my past shelties did not bark too much except if left out for long periods of time. Now my Danny Boy loves to run around and bark at birds, boats, helicopters, ducks etc. But he is only doing what his breed was meant to do. My neighbors two little dogs never bark. But when you get a sheltie you must be prepared for behavior typical to the breed and vocalizing is one of them. It doesn't bother us sheltie lovers hence we keep getting more and more of them.:smile2:
 
Exactly not all of mine are what I'd like to call chronic barkers! I only really have one and that is Molly. The rest of mine will bark and I do t really mind it but when I tell them no bark. They all comply. Except of course Molly. Hence why she was bark softened! I could not risk noise complaints from her nor do I think it's fair to have my neighbors listen to it!


Dr Mac I did not have her done in RI. There was a vet in warren that used to do it but I'm not even sure if they do anymore. So essentially the bill is garbage.
 
If a sheltie or for that matter any other breed is barking excessively and if it is a matter of keeping it or taking it to the pound I would not hesitate to suggest debarking if all else fails.
 
Yes, that was why I was asking about Buddy. When he plays and runs, he constantly barks. Then I tell him "Quiet" and he stops everything and looks so sad. I used to have 5 acres with my other 6 shelties, and I didn't really care if they barked...no neighbors to care about it. Now I live in a house with a small yard and some of the neighbors' dogs bark, so I don't really care if he barks here. What I'm worried about is that I've never had a sheltie in an apartment, and we are getting to old to keep moving. Does that mean that the best thing to do would be to give Buddy away? I don't know how I could live without him. Here in California, with the bad economy, good dogs are going to the pound by the dozens. Every other house seems to be foreclosed and the apartment rent prices have gone way up. Most of the apartments won't take dogs. I will not debark Buddy unless I have no choice, and that would be if we were going to be evicted because of Buddy's barking. It's really not that much barking, but I won't know what to expect until we get there.

Dayle
 
Maybe i miss read your post, but how is it a better option to give Danny away and with the shelters full they will euthanize him, than a simple 5 min procedure???
 
Wait and see what happens. I understand your concern. If you can provide exercise for your sheltie (walks) than that shouldn't be a problem. Now if you get complaints or feel he is barking excessively than I would debark rather than give him up. If you ever have to give him up consider sheltie rescue.
I am shocked at how many dogs are in the pound in CA. Most are euthanized.
 
Maybe i miss read your post, but how is it a better option to give Danny away and with the shelters full they will euthanize him, than a simple 5 min procedure???

I think you got my Danny confused with Buddy. Just reading that sent a chill down my spine. We would never get rid of Danny. Never ever. I agree with you. California is experiencing a crisis in pet surrenders. I am in contact with people out there and they are so saddened by what is going on. That's why I posted about the sheltie out there (got rescued today). I would debark Buddy if need be it could save his life.
 
Crystal1, definitely wait and see what happens. I went from a house with a backyard to an apartment. I've been in the apartment since May and ::knock on wood:: I haven't had any complaints.

Despite Bailey's many behavior problems, she is surprisingly not much of a barker in the apartment. From a young age, I instilled in her that if you bark, all the fun stops. If you bark when playing, I stop playing with you. If you bark when I'm making your food, I stop preparing your food. She is my only dog and there are no other dogs in my building, so there's no other dog for her to bark along with.
She does bark when my neighbors are in the hallway and when the phone or doorbell rings. I'm still trying to get her to stop doing that, but other than those situations, she's pretty quiet.

She will look out the window and bark if she sees skateboarders or other dogs. My living rooom window goes down to the floor, so I had to tape a sheet (2 feet high) to the window, so she can't look out.

What I'm trying to say is there are ways to prevent their barking if you know what sets them off. If looking out the window makes them bark, then block their access to the window like I did. If he barks when you play, then end his play sessions and start playing when he is quiet. He'll figure it out sooner than you think.

If your dog's barking can't be controlled through prevention or training and you are getting complaints, then you can always considering bark softening (debarking). If that doesn't help and you must rehome him, contact a sheltie rescue in your area.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top