Update On Bailey...

Randi, I don't have much advice to offer but I do want to tell you how sorry I am you are having these issues. I know how tough it is in an apt. building. Do know you are an amazing Mom and I admire your patience and persistence to try anything possible to help Bailey out.
 
Oh Randi, I am so sorry you are struggling with Bailey. I know how much you love her and how much she loves you....

My hope for you is that you can enjoy your upcoming weekend at your parents' and you and Bailey can have some fun, relaxing time together and with your family. Bailey will be with family as opposed to strangers in your building so hopefully she will know that and you won't have to worry about biting...

We had friends from CT visit us this past weekend and in the beginning all 3 pups went crazy with barking and overall wild behavior. Once they realized they were friends they settled down and the rest of the visit was fine.

One other thing...I remember when our Bailey was uncontrollable on walks. Really uncontrollable. I felt hopeless about it and I didn't think she would ever be a dog I could take on walks. I can't tell you exactly when it turned around but it did and now I am able to take her on walks.

Hang in there, Randi. You are doing all the right things and now you just need time for it to all come together...
 
Honestly, I think I would have to work with your dog to have a sense of what's going on with it. It almost sounds in these messages as if your dog is escalating - would that be correct?

If this was my dog, or a dog I was training, these are the possibilities that would run through my mind (and please, please, please don't take any of them offensively - it's a mental checklist - it comes out a lot politer when I'm talking to clients)

1. Bad breeding. I would want to know who the breeder was, what the lines are like, what socialization was provided, how soon the pup was separated from the parents, whether the dog was a singleton, whether these behaviours have always been present or whether the behaviours have escalated since you've owned her. If it's been since you've owned her, I would want to know when you took ownership, and when she started to escalate.

2. Medical problem: The only dog I ever coached who escalated instead of de-escalated had a tumour in his brain. I would bring your dog to the vet, and ask him/her to run the complete gamut of tests. I've seen great dogs turn mean because of a pulled shoulder, back injury, sore paw, and bad tooth. I'm sure the vets can add to this, but I would definitely be doing a full check up including all relevant blood tests (this is actually the first thing I would do if it was one of my dogs).

3. Training. If it's not the breeding/socialization, and it's not a medical issue, now I go to training. If the dog is escalating, there's probably a real miscommunication going on between you and your dog. Your dog may be anxious, frustrated, or confused, and using these aggressive displays to account for the problem. I would say this is the problem with at least 90% of the owners who come to me saying their dog is aggressive - it's not a dog issue, it's a communication issue between the owner and the dog. You need a good trainer. The problem is, of course, a lot of trainers say they are good (and probably think they're good), but the reality is they have no clue what they're doing. By the way, "behaviourists" don't always know what they're talking about either. I'd ask them what methods they plan on using - counter condition and positive reinforcement is good, flooding and dominance is bad (and potentially disastrous, from what you've written). If they have no clue what you're talking about when you mention those terms, walk away.

4. Environment. If all else fails, the environment needs to change. Bailey can't be put into a position where she will react this way. The more she gets used to reacting, the more deeply engrained the behaviour will become. That may mean that you have to take the stairs, or get up at three in the morning to practice appropriate elevator entrances and exits. It may mean that you have to beg your friends to act as "strangers", so you can practice appropriate behaviour skills. You need to set her up for success - avoid what's setting her off (for now) and build her confidence in other areas, then gradually reintroduce the problem area.

I remember you saying that the trainers and behaviourists in your area are ridiculously expensive. I'm so sorry about that - most trainers here charge about $50 - $60 an hour for a private lesson (and those are top level trainers!). Really research your trainer - having a bad trainer will be a financial hit and have a negative impact on an already difficult solution. If the cost is prohibitive, consider a group class - I've had tons of reactive dogs in my group classes, and it actually works out well because it's a fantastic opportunity to practice behaviours. If you can afford a group class with an excellent instructor, instead of a private lesson with a mediocre instructor, that's the route I would take.

I know you're really worried about Bailey, and I wish you the best of luck. This whole situation must be so frustrating for you. I think you're doing a great job of seeking advice and exploring options. I hope this gave you at least a few more ideas, and again, I apologize if it came off as abrupt - it's not meant to be - I'm just exhausted and about to hit the sack once this is posted :sleepy:
 
I’ve been there with Snap… not in elevators, but with lunging and barking after people / dogs that are walking away from peaceful greetings.

The only suggestion I would add would be to work on alternate behaviors and to practice and proactively use them as a management technique. Do you have a let’s go command, for example ?

If you do, practice that inside your apartment, such that Bailey will heel up to a target with you, then pivot with you and happily walk away from the target, then get rewarded. You might then take this to the apt building hallway, perhaps walking part way down the hall towards the elevator, pivoting and going back to your door; and gradually walking to the elevator and returning to your door.

Find a time on the weekend when things are relatively quiet and practice with a friend in the elevator. Have the friend stand near the door, while you and Bailey are at the back. When the door opens, do a 180, 270, or a few 360s with Bailey before your friend takes a step and ask Bailey for a sit or down, a hand touch, or a trick…. something to engage her thinking brain and prevent the reactive part of the brain from kicking in, while allowing your friend to make a safe exit. You might take the elevator up / down a floor and repeat this on other floors as well as at the lobby level.

When this is successful with a friend, then I’d recruit a neighbor for practice, then perhaps a different neighbor, and gradually up the ante to one with a shopping cart or rolling suitcase, etc. or two neighbors in the elevator...

Regardless, stage your training, mix it up so that Bailey can’t predict what is going to happen, reward heavily for success. Hopefully, you can create a new elevator behavior which is fun, as opposed to stressful.
 
3Stars, here's answers to some of your questions...

1) I'm not going to post the kennel's name on a public forum, but I do believe the breeder was more concerned with conformation than temperament. I never met Bailey's parents. Father is from a different kennel and the mother was sold shortly before I picked up Bailey. The breeder said her mother had couldn't walk well on leash, so she could not show her anymore. I believe her mom was very shy. I got Bailey when she was 10 weeks old. She is from a litter of 3 and there was another litter of 5 puppies that was a week younger than Bailey. Her mother's milk dried up a few days after her puppies were born, so I'm not sure how much interaction Bailey had with her mother. The breeder had to bottle feed the puppies. Bailey was socialized with other dogs and people after she had her rabies shot. I took her to the park at least every weekend.

2) I had Bailey examined by a vet and did some bloods tests in March. Everything came back normal. I don't believe she has any physical injuries. We practice agility twice a week and she has shown no signs of pain. I also brush her teeth every other day and have not noticed any teeth or mouth issues.

3) I absolutely believe my dog is anxious and frustrated. That is the issue.

4) Unfortunately, the environment can not change. I work in Manhattan and can't move. Of course I can take the stairs instead of the elevator and I that is something I just started today. If I hear the elevator moving that means someone is in it and we will take the stairs, but I can't control when my neighbors are entering or exiting the building.

We do take a group class. We take agility classes twice a week. Bailey is not as reactive when she is around a group of dogs.

Bailey was a little better on her walk this morning. No reactivity towards dogs or people. Thankfully, we didn't encounter anyone in my building. I made sure I walked across the street if I saw any dogs. Last night, she was very hyper and barked a lot in the apartment. She woke me up 3 times in the middle of the night because my neighbor went in and out of her apartment. I still have no idea how to train her not to bark when my neighbor closes her apartment door.

I do have some videos. I was trying to record Bailey's behavior to make a little montage video. I only have a few example clips of her barking. I don't have any footage of barking in my apartment when my neighbor opens & closes her door. I also don't have her barking in the elevator or in building when sees a neighbor. And no footage of her shadow chasing or barking when me or my roommate leave her alone.. I'll try to get more footage this weekend. It's just hard to walk her, treat her and film her at the same time. Plus, I think she knows I'm filming her, because she tends to be angel as soon as I turn the camera on.

I'm at work right now, so this videos are unedited....

Bad Bailey
1) Barking and lunging at non-reactive dogs
http://s75.photobucket.com/albums/i...vior Videos/?action=view&current=VID00007.mp4
http://s75.photobucket.com/albums/i...vior Videos/?action=view&current=VID00012.mp4

2) Barking at skateboarders
http://s75.photobucket.com/albums/i...vior Videos/?action=view&current=VID00005.mp4

Good Bailey
1) Sees a dog
http://s75.photobucket.com/albums/i...vior Videos/?action=view&current=VID00014.mp4
2) Walking past screaming children
http://s75.photobucket.com/albums/i...vior Videos/?action=view&current=VID00013.mp4
 
I would up the criteria with the MM now that Bailey understands it. Bailey should only get treats for giving the desired behavior. The desired behavior does not involve barking. Otherwise, you are treating and thus rewarding for the barking behavior as well as going to the bed. I doubt you want to reward the barking.
 

Randi, I'm going to video Bentley the next time we take him for a walk and when he hears dogs in our backyard. I know it isn't helpful, but hopefully it will make you feel better.
 
Randi, I'm going to video Bentley the next time we take him for a walk and when he hears dogs in our backyard. I know it isn't helpful, but hopefully it will make you feel better.

Thanks. I'm pretty sure her lunging at other dogs is quite common. I'm not as concerned about that as I am with her recent lunging at random people, after strangers pet her and at people in my building/elevator. I also don't know know how to get her to stop barking at my neighbor every time she closes her door. She becomes so crazy that she doesn't follow commands.

I'd also like to note that Bailey wasn't this bad when I lived with my parents in a quiet neighborhood with a backyard. During morning walks, she only had to encounter 0-3 dogs and maybe 2 people. She has gotten much worse since we moved into an apartment in a busy neighborhood, where she sees at least 3 dogs and 25 people every walk.

I'm just a little conflicted. I'm debating if I should spend $200 on a behaviorist trainer or $400 on a veterinary behaviorist. I'd hate to spend $200 on a trainer just to be told that she might need medication.
 
Back
Top