Definitely a Sheltie. They all go through that gangly teenage phase...heck, Bacca is 18 months, and he's still all legs and feathers only just coming in. And is most definitely not BYB....though not show himself (too big)
So glad you all agree that Our Buddy Rob Roy is truly a Sheltie!! It isn't fair to compare him to Maggie Mae who was a show puppy. She actually turned out to be too small and was sold to a man who neglected her and we were the lucky ones who rescued her!! That's when we fell in love with Shelties!!
The breeder didn't do any of the dewclaws and the ones on the back look really strange. Our vet said it would require surgery now and be awfully painful so we aren't going to do it.