Why Won't Other Dogs Play With Ellie?

I have read online that shelties are the only dogs that seem to be bigotted against other breeds. I also found that to be true when I owned the three shelties. Occassionally my foster daughter would insist that she didn't like shelties and wanted a dog of her own--a different breed. She had a golden retriever for a while, then a rottweiller. The other shelties would not except them into their little group, and would stand around barking at the different breed dogs. I rehomed the golden retriever and rottweiller, since my daughter never liked them much, after she got to know their personalities.

Later, someone asked if they could drop off their sheltie for a few months, just until they could find a place that would allow dogs. The shelties added him to their group immediately and he fit right in. A few years later the woman came and picked him up (no thanks, no pay for food and medical), the other shelties were sad for a little while.

I have to agree with others that any of the herding group would probably be a better match, than just any breed. I have been trying to set up Buddy up with a Corgi down the street, but I keep missing her owner.

To tell you the truth, that's the biggest reason I like having more than 1 sheltie, so that they can have a pal when I can't be there. My husband says maybe later, so I keep praying.

I am seeing that here,honestly with Trapp & Earnhardt.Trapp wants to go go all the time,and Earnhardt is very mellow,and is past his hard play times. He does at least once a day,get zoomies,but is not at all like Trapp in any sense of energy.

I can see where the addtion of another sheltie would be an added playmate for Trapp. We'll add on here,in another year or so. Earnhardt is getting up there in years.He just can't play like Trapp wants him to.
 
My puppy class teacher called Dylan a cheerleader. He didn't participate in playing with other puppies, but ran around a circle barking at them. He loves to be chased but not that many dogs in the park are fast or agile enough to catch hime and gives up soon. I always thought he was a little social outcast like me. Now he is 3.5 years old and when we go to a dog park, he is still awkard. My husband and I normally ended up chasing him or playing ball with him. However, he plays like normal dog with his sister, a maltese at home. They mouth each other and wrestle each other on the counch. I think he reserves this special play with his sister only but with no other dogs. :smile2:
 
My puppy class teacher called Dylan a cheerleader. He didn't participate in playing with other puppies, but ran around a circle barking at them.

That's funny that your instructor called your pup a "cheerleader"--ours called Bentley the "play police" because he did the same thing. Barked and ran around them "monitoring" the event haha!
 
I have read online that shelties are the only dogs that seem to be bigotted against other breeds.

Interesting. Shiba's are like this too. Saw some upturned noses at the park one day. lol. Then the two Shiba's would only play with each other. It was funny.

I'm beginning to get the feeling that our pups just don't like to play like most other dogs. I wonder if all herding dogs are like this, or is it just ours? lol.
 
That's funny that your instructor called your pup a "cheerleader"--ours called Bentley the "play police" because he did the same thing. Barked and ran around them "monitoring" the event haha!

That's our Annie Laurie: "Hall Monitor to the World."
 
Herding breeds have a different play style than other dogs - they love the chase, but not the catch and wrestle part.
 
That's funny that your instructor called your pup a "cheerleader"--ours called Bentley the "play police" because he did the same thing. Barked and ran around them "monitoring" the event haha!

Well, think about it! They are sheep herders! At puppy school, they want to herd the other pups into line! No wonder they aren't popular! They are control freaks! They are the nerds of puppy school!
 
Well, think about it! They are sheep herders! At puppy school, they want to herd the other pups into line! No wonder they aren't popular! They are control freaks! They are the nerds of puppy school!

Too funny - our dogs are obsessive compulsive control freaks - what does that say about us.:lol:
 
Well, think about it! They are sheep herders! At puppy school, they want to herd the other pups into line! No wonder they aren't popular! They are control freaks! They are the nerds of puppy school!
LOL! Phebe barks instructions to the other dogs in agility class. She gets so worked up watching them run that I often take her off to the side to work on handling cues because she sucks at waiting. :winkgrin:
 
Too funny - our dogs are obsessive compulsive control freaks - what does that say about us.:lol:

Yikes! That is how I'm described at work too! And matching dog personality to people personality does that mean that Sheltie owners are essetionally compulsive types?

Sorry to hijack this thread, but I think we now have a new conversation going!
 
Back
Top